Rekey vs. Replace in Edmond, OK: What’s Best for Your Home or Business?
Move-in day, lost keys, tenant turnover, or a security refresh? Here’s the clear, local Edmond guide to choosing between rekeying and replacing locks—costs, timing, pros/cons, and practical checklists.
When you move into a new property in Edmond—or if you’ve lost keys, had a tenant move out, or simply want more control over who has access—you’ll face the classic question: Should I rekey my locks, or replace them?
At Thunder Locksmith, we help Edmond homeowners, landlords, and businesses choose the right path daily. This guide explains the differences, costs, and local factors so you can make a confident decision and keep your doors secure.
What Does Rekeying a Lock Mean?
Rekeying changes the internal pin configuration inside your existing lock cylinder so the old keys no longer work. You keep the same hardware on the door but receive a brand-new key that operates it.
- Fast & affordable compared to full replacement.
- Same look — hardware stays; curb appeal unaffected.
- Security reset — ideal after you move in or a tenant moves out.
- Key-alike option — make multiple doors work with one key.
In Edmond, rekeying is popular for same-day move-ins, quick rental turnovers, and for new buyers who want peace of mind without changing every lock.
What Does Replacing a Lock Mean?
Replacing a lock means installing entirely new hardware—this could be a sturdier deadbolt, high-security cylinder, or a smart lock with keypad/app control.
- Upgrade options — stronger deadbolts, smart features, new finishes.
- Fix damage/wear — solves sticking, rust, or builder-grade hardware issues.
- Style refresh — match new door colors or HOA-approved finishes.
Rekey vs Replace: Quick Comparison
| Feature | Rekeying | Replacing |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Lower (per cylinder) | Higher (hardware + install) |
| Time | Fast (≈15–20 mins/lock) | Longer (fit/adjust/setup) |
| Look | Same hardware/finish | New style/finish |
| Best for | Move-ins, lost keys, tenant turnover | Upgrades, damage, smart features |
| Security | Equivalent if hardware is solid | Can increase with better tech/hardware |
How Much Does It Cost in Edmond?
Rekeying Costs
- Standard rekey (per cylinder): $19 – $35
- Local Edmond service call: $29 – $45
- After-hours/emergency: $75 – $150
Example: Front door deadbolt + handle set (2 cylinders) typically totals $85–$120.
Replacement Costs
- Basic deadbolt replacement: $65 – $120 (plus hardware)
- High-security/keypad/smart lock: $125 – $250+
- Full home (3–5 doors): $300 – $700 depending on brand/grade
Example: Upgrading three doors to keypad smart locks typically runs $450–$550 installed.
When to Choose Rekeying
- Just moved into an Edmond home and want a quick security reset.
- Tenant moved out; you need fresh keys without changing hardware.
- You lost a key but your locks are still in good condition.
- You want multiple doors to work with a single key (“key alike”).
When to Choose Replacement
- Locks are worn, sticking, rusted, or builder-grade.
- You want smart features, audit trails, or keypad convenience.
- You’re refreshing finishes to match doors/trim or meet HOA requests.
- Insurance or security standards suggest stronger hardware.
Edmond-Specific Tips
- HOA finishes: Some Edmond communities prefer consistent exterior finishes. If looks must stay the same, rekeying is the easy win.
- Weather durability: Oklahoma storms/humidity can age cheap locks quickly. If you see corrosion, replacement is smarter long-term.
- Move-in routine: Realtors commonly recommend same-day rekeying at closing to control all keys immediately.
Quick Edmond Case Example
A family in Coffee Creek bought a home with relatively new locks but received multiple old key sets. We compared options:
- Replace: ≈ $450+ for new hardware across doors
- Rekey: ≈ $110 for exterior doors, 5 new keys
They chose rekeying, kept the look, and saved several hundred dollars.
Rekey vs Replace — Edmond FAQ
Is rekeying as safe as replacing?
Yes—if your existing lock is in good condition. Rekeying fully resets key access. If the hardware itself is weak or damaged, replacement is the right move.
How long does it take?
Rekeying averages 15–20 minutes per lock. Replacement typically takes 20–40 minutes depending on fitment and setup.
Can I rekey my locks myself?
DIY kits exist, but incorrect pinning can jam cylinders or reduce security. Most Edmond homeowners prefer a pro for clean results and guaranteed function.
Should landlords rekey between tenants?
Yes. It’s an inexpensive way to maintain key control, reduce liability, and protect new occupants. Many property managers treat rekeying as a standard turnover step.
What about smart locks—rekey or replace?
Most smart locks require replacement because they use different internal components. If you want keypad/app access or Apple/Google home integration, go with a smart deadbolt install.
Will insurance cover rekeying after a break-in?
Sometimes policies cover repairs after forced entry. Preventive rekeying may be out-of-pocket, but it’s often recommended as part of restoring key control.
Thunder Locksmith — Simple Edmond Packages
- New Homeowner Package: Rekey up to 5 locks + 4 new keys (flat rate)
- Landlord Package: Tenant move-out rekey + optional master keying
- Smart Upgrade Package: Install keypad/smart deadbolt with app support
Ready to secure your Edmond property today?
📞 Call Thunder Locksmith: 405-500-KEYS
🌐 www.thunderlocksmith.com
💬 Prefer texting? Send a photo of your lock, and we’ll quote fast. If this guide helped, leave a quick Google review so Edmond neighbors can find us faster. It really helps local homeowners & small businesses.